EU tariffs add to pressure on China's EV makers
June 12, 2024
EU policymakers warned a few months ago that Europe was being flooded with cheap Chinese electric vehicles . They accused Beijing of backing major production overcapacity to allow China's automakers to grow their share of the global EV market.
The European Commission, the EU's executive arm, launched an anti-subsidy probe into the oversupply issue late in 2023 and warned China's EV makers that they could face a new import tariff to offset what Brussels said was unfair competition for European carmakers.
On Wednesday, the Commission said it was planning to impose tariffs of up to 38% on Chinese electric vehicles from July 4 and those tariffs would vary by automaker. The EU currently levies a 10% tariff. The announcement prompted a warning of retaliation by Beijing.
The United States is due to levy a 100% import tax on Chinese-made electric cars, up from the current 25%, which will effectively keep Chinese automakers out of the US market.
While most industrial companies in Germany support the tariffs, according to a study by the Cologne-based Institute for Economic Research (IW), Volker Treier, head of foreign trade at the German Chamber of Industry and Commerce (DIHK) warned the move would have consequences for Europe's largest economy, which relies on exports to China.
Chinese carmaker exits Europe HQ
If the threat from Chinese automakers is so large, why did Great Wall Motor, China's seventh largest car manufacturer, announce last week it was closing its European headquarters in Munich, southern Germany, due to disappointing sales?
The decision sparked speculation about China's ability to compete in the European automotive market and whether the canceled plans were part of Beijing's retaliation against possible EU tariffs or purely for economic reasons.
"Although there is lots of noise around the arrival of Chinese car brands in Europe, they are still something of a rarity — evidenced by the slow uptick in registrations over the past year," Felipe Munoz, senior analyst at the London-based auto research firm JATO Dynamics, said in a recent research note.
Munoz told DW that not all 24 Chinese car brands currently expanding into Europe will succeed as it is a "very difficult market."
"People in Europe don't know these brands. You need to work to change the image that people still have that China produces only low-quality products. And that takes time, a lot of time," he said.
Chinese brands achieved a 2.35% market share in Europe in April this year, compared to 2.2% over the same month in 2023, according to JATO Dynamics data. Only one Chinese carmaker, BYD, made the top 15 electric vehicle sellers in Europe in the same month.
UK legacy brand helps China's numbers
The lack of traction for Chinese automakers in Europe is made worse when you consider that MG, which has been owned by China's state-owned SAIC Motor since 2007, is still widely perceived as a British brand. In April, MG accounted for 68% of the 25,360 total units registered by Chinese brands in Europe.
Separate car tracking data of imports rather than sales, reported in the Financial Times, showed that 20% of all electric vehicle deliveries to Europe in the first four months of the year were made in China.
The Financial Times reported that European sales of Chinese EVs had grown by 23% in the first four months of the year. Even so, European carmakers will likely have multiple advantages over their Chinese peers for some time to come, analysts said.
"Chinese companies have great cars but have less experience in marketing these vehicles," Ferdinand Dudenhöffer, the founder of Ferdi Research and formerly director of the Center for Automotive Research, told DW. He added that Great Wall had hoped to use the existing dealerships of their competitors to sell their vehicles to European consumers, which he said was "the wrong approach."
Price cut seen as desperate measure
After disappointing sales — with just 6,300 new registrations in Europe last year — Great Wall was joined by some EV automakers in a price war, offering discounts.
"When you lower the purchase price, you destroy the resale value of the car, which damages your brand's reputation in the long term," said Dudenhöffer.
The closure of the Munich headquarters is a major setback for Great Wall, which had previously sought to build its own factory in Europe as part of huge expansion plans for the continent.
Last month, the company pledged to sell a million cars abroad by 2030, up from 316,018 last year. The Chinese automaker insists it had no plans to exit the market and said its European operations will be managed from its headquarters in China.
Battery makers U-turn on German projects
Great Wall's announcement came on the heels of two Chinese EV battery makers' decisions to scrap new facilities in Germany. Former Great Wall subsidiary SVOLT said last month it would no longer build a battery cell plant in the eastern German state of Brandenburg. The battery maker blamed the cancellation of a large customer order for its decision.
"There may be political reasons behind this decision. Beijing is really not happy about the prospect of EU tariffs, so we can expect retaliation measures," Munoz told DW.
In December, rival CATL also halted plans to expand its first cell plant abroad, in the eastern German state of Thuringia, again citing falling demand. However, the battery maker is building its second plant in Hungary, which has grown closer to Beijing even as some of its EU peers look to diversify away from China.
Along with domestic players, Chinese EV makers and battery producers are being affected by easing demand for electric vehicles in Europe. Government subsidies are being withdrawn, and European consumers remain wary of the many cons of e-motoring, including battery range anxiety and poor resale value of electric vehicles.
"Electric cars are still very dependent on [government] incentives," said Munoz. "We're still not there in terms of affordability because even a €20,000 ($21,000) electric vehicle is not an affordable car."
Other Chinese carmakers stick around
Other Chinese carmakers are still planning ambitious expansion in Europe, including NIO, which has just added its seventh NIO House showroom on the continent, located in Amsterdam. As of May, the firm has six mass-produced EV models for sale in the European market.
Rival XPeng recently announced plans to enter the German, French, Italian and UK markets. The automaker already operates in several Nordic countries and the Netherlands.
Stellantis, the auto giant formed out of Fiat and Peugeot-owner PSA, said last month it had agreed on a joint venture with Chinese carmaker Leapmotor to sell its electric vehicles in Europe.
This piece was updated on June 12, 2024 to reflect the EU Commission's decision to impose tariffs on Chinese electric vehicle imports.
Edited by: Ashutosh Pandey